September 2004 Voting Results for RCA!
| Nominee | Votes |
| "The Quest for the Legends" by Dragonfree | 35 |
| "Passion Under Fire" by The Jolt Master | 27 |
| "Let Love Be Your Energy" by Cultnirvana | 25 |
| "I'll Be Home For Christmas - The Extended Version" by Finaille Nailo | 25 |
| "Pokemon Meets Yu-Gi-Oh!" by Yami Ash | 25 |
| "This Pichu is Different" by Misty101803 | 23 |
| "My Biggest Mistake" by Lonepichu | 22 |
| "My Tender Strength" by A*mon | 21 |
| "A Christmas Story" by Angel Kitten | 21 |
| "The Madness of Viridian City" by Dannichu | 21 |
| "Stolen Bike, Stolen Heart" by Desiree | 21 |
| "No Matter What" by Emerald Dragon & Topaz | 21 |
| "Can We Just Take A Walk?" by Toto | 21 |
| "$42.50" by Cyberwraith9 | 20 |
| "Pokémon: Eternal Legacies" by Mikazuchi | 20 |
| "Revelation of the Master" by Pokemon Fan | 20 |
| "Death No Obstacle" by Cultnirvana | 19 |
| "Resolutions" by Cultnirvana | 19 |
| "Hold On" by Torchick | 19 |
| "Fate's Game" by E_Eevee | 18 |
| "Love And War" by Spruceton Spook | 18 |
| "Opposite Passions" by Finaille Nailo | 17 |
| "Code: Pokemon" by Hero of Time | 17 |
| "Pokémon Neo, Book 5: Giovanni's Experimentations" by Kenta Macauttum | 17 |
| "Ash in Battle City" by Master Yami Cami | 17 |
| "Ash on Misty?" by Ash on Mist | 16 |
| "Love Pallet" by Kenshin | 16 |
| "Love's End" by Misty101803 | 16 |
| "The Journey of Poke'mon" by Soccerpixie | 16 |
| "Pikachu" by Agent 99 | 15 |
| "Destiny" by Brian | 15 |
| "Adventures of the Clinically Strange" by Dannichu | 15 |
| "Coming Back" by Erina-chan | 15 |
| "Take Me As I Am" by M. T. Tasaki | 15 |
| "Whenever, Wherever" by R.A.W. | 15 |
| "Nightfall" by Torchick | 15 |
| "Battles of the Legendaries" by Blastoise | 14 |
| "Enter the Dark Mew" by Diamond Eevie | 14 |
| "Kaleidescope" by Erina-chan | 14 |
| "Prickly Heat" by Erina-chan | 14 |
| "Only the Pure Hearts Survive" by Pidgey Master | 14 |
| "The Legendary Quest: The Watcher" by R.A.W. | 14 |
| "The League Prom" by Squirtle'sGurl07 | 14 |
| "Pokemon Reborn" by Super Pikachu | 14 |
| "Crooked" by A Silent Rain | 13 |
| "Humans: From the Pokémon's Point Of View" by Ashla | 13 |
| "Moon Fang" by Crystal | 13 |
| "The Distance from Yesterday" by Fish | 13 |
| "Goodbye, Raichu" by Raichu | 13 |
| "A Vacation For Lurve" by Silver Angel | 13 |
| "Tangled Web" by ChicRocketJames | 12 |
| "Everything Changes" by Dragoness Bahamut | 12 |
| "Changing Times" by E_Eevee | 12 |
| "Lost Thoughts" by Legacy | 12 |
| "Eternal Winter" by Pika-Zukin | 12 |