October 2009 Voting Results for RCA!
| Nominee | Votes |
| "Spooked" by Spruceton Spook | 11 |
| "Twisted Hierarchy" by Obsidian Blade | 10 |
| "Making My Way" by Dragoness Bahamut | 9 |
| "Through Darkness Shines Love" by Pikagurl23 | 8 |
| "Yu and Mie" by A Second Cousin to Morty | 7 |
| "Can't Get My Love Together" by Erina-chan | 7 |
| "The Mirror-World Menace" by Andrew | 6 |
| "The Distance From Yesterday" by Fish | 6 |
| "Legends of the Tide" by Mystic Vaporeon | 6 |
| "Dreaming" by Mirei | 5 |